Human resource (HR) systems that invest in employees reliably predict organizational performance, yet important meta-analytic evidence shows their benefits are often larger where they fit the surrounding national culture least well. We reconcile this paradox regarding individualism/collectivism with signaling theory: high-investment human resource systems (HIHRS) are costly, credible signals of an organization’s intent to invest in employees, and such signals are most informative where they distinguish from cultural framing, so their meaning is amplified in more collectivistic settings through attention rather than value congruence. We test this argument across five studies at two levels of analysis. A meta-analytic path model based on 184 papers with 187 studies shows that societal collectivism amplifies the employee-focused mediation chain from HIHRS to firm performance (Study 1 with a supplemental subset analysis). Three vignette experiments designed to establish causality from HIHRS to employee outcomes (Study 2a), from HIHRS to signals (Study 2b), and from signals to employee outcomes (Study 2c) provide strong evidence for the causal chain advanced in this manuscript. Finally, we conducted another experiment with a more realistic fictious company webpages with individualistic vs. collectivistic HR practices (Study 3) to further demonstrate that the impact of (collectivistic) HR practices in culturally inconsistent settings has a larger impact on employee attitudes. The meta-analytic and experimental evidence together triangulate on a signaling account of when investment in employees is most clearly communicated.